Pipe Spring National Monument – cultures clashing over water

Pipe Spring National Monument

On my drive back from Utah, I decided to stop at two locations important to the Honeymoon Trail (read more about that here or here) and now part of the rich history of the American west.

Pipe Spring National Monument

Pipe Spring National Monument is located off Highway 389 between Hurricane, Utah and Fredonia, Arizona on the Arizona Strip, which is a large relatively flat plain that covers thousands of acres just north of the Grand Canyon. This NM is on the Kaibab-Paiute Reservation and tells the story of three distinct cultures, belief systems and peoples who interacted in this region.

Those three groups of people are the Native Americans who have called this region home and used the water from the spring for hundreds of years before White settlers came to town; the Mormons who used the Arizona Strip as a cattle ranch and claimed possession of the spring by building a fort over the top of it to control the water for agriculture, distribution, etc.; and the U.S. government with its explorers and later the National Park Service.

This site is a brilliant example of misunderstanding between cultures and how it can affect everything from a way of life to the land itself.

A visit to Pipe Spring NM begins in the visitors’ center and museum where the story of all three groups is told – the good, the bad and the ugly. Most interestingly the disputes that happened there are similar to disputes today about the rights to natural resources, in this case the most valuable – water.

When you leave the museum you enter National Park Service property. It is a small site with the historic building known as Winsor Castle, the spring with holding ponds, examples of agriculture from all times of occupation, and other auxiliary structures.

Pipe Spring National Monument Winsor Castle

Every half hour a tour of the fort begins led by a ranger. It takes you through all of the rooms of the building. Most interesting are the personal anecdotes from those who previously lived there. Our ranger seemed to have done a lot of research and knew the former residents quite well.

After the tour, I took the short rim trail that takes you up the ridge behind the house with grand vistas of the Arizona Strip and some beautiful desert landscape.

inside Winsor Castle at Pipe Spring National Monumentthe Arizona Strip from Pipe Spring National MonumentTexas longhorn at Pipe Spring National Monument

In the early 1920s, the first director of the National Park Service was making the trip between Zion NP and Grand Canyon NP. He planned to make a quick stop at Pipe Spring, but due to car problems ended up staying about a week. During that time he learned the rich history of this site and decided it should be preserved. It also happens to be a great half-way point for people going between those two larger national parks especially back then when cars traveled slower on not-so-great roads. Anyway, he went back to D.C. and had Pipe Spring designated a national monument.

I highly recommend a stop here. If you’re making the trip from Zion to Grand Canyon or vice versa or just traveling from Arizona to Utah, take an hour or two to get caught up on the history of this region.

My next stop, Lee’s Ferry, is detailed in the next post.

3 responses to “Pipe Spring National Monument – cultures clashing over water

  1. Did the native Americans ever get access again after the fort was built? Interesting story about a place I haven’t heard of.

    • They made the water available to everyone but not in the way it was before. The Mormon settlers tried to get along with the natives unlike most American pioneers settling the west. But here lies one of the biggest example of clashing cultures, the indigenous people didn’t believe in owning the rights to water or anything for that matter so they didn’t understand why anyone would control its access. Perhaps the biggest demise to the Native population though wasn’t the water rights but how over-grazing from the ranch stock turned the once very fertile Arizona Strip into sagebrush desert. The history is fascinating. There is so much more to the story including Navajo slave traders, Powell’s surveying expeditions and hiding polygamists. Hope you have a chance to visit and learn more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.